Show Contents
Hide Contents
Best Hypoallergenic Eyeliners for Sensitive Eyes and Sensitive Eyelids Review
For quite a few decades, women all around the world have used make up to beautify themselves. The eyeliner is one of these makeup instruments. While the eyeliner is a perfect beautifying material, it also comes with its own drawback. Being artificially made, some contents within the eyeliner might not go well with particular kinds of skin textures. When this happens, the skin will begin to react and start irritating. Depending on the dermatology of the person involved, this irritation can take different forms, some more severe than others. These days, however, this is no longer a problem due to the ingenuity of beautifying houses and makeup manufacturers. Over the years, manufacturers have perfected the art of producing eyeliners that don’t react negatively with the skin no matter the skin texture. These eyeliners are best described as hypoallergenic and they are certified by medical experts such as ophthalmologists and dermatologists.
For those beautiful ladies with sensitive eyes and eyelids, the option of a hypoallergenic eyeliner is the best choice for you. You can easily apply your make up without any fear of an after effect or irritation that will leave you searching for another product to quiet the effects. Luckily for us, this guide talks about the top 10 best hypoallergenic eyeliners on the market in 2020.
The 10 Best Hypoallergenic Eyeliners for Sensitive Eyes and Sensitive Eyelids Reviewed
Below are some of the best eyeliners and their reviews.
1
Neutrogena Nourishing Eyeliner Pencil
If you are looking for the best hypoallergenic eyeliner on the market and a long term make up partner that can service your many beauty needs, then you should definitely check out this wonderful product manufactured by Neutrogena. This eyeliner is described as nourishing because it is made with refreshing organic materials such as rainforest shea butter and olive oil. You can rest assured that this eyeliner works perfectly fine with any skin type or texture including sensitive ones. If for one reason or another, you utilize contact lens, this eyeliner is also safe for you. Water-resistant, long-lasting, easy to apply, and approved by multiple health professionals. This product is first on our review for a reason. It has been used by multiple customers all over the world and they all agree that this product is one of the best
Key Features:
- Made from olive oil and shea butter
- Comes with a built-in sharpener
- Suitable for sensitive eyes; dermatologist approved
- Long-lasting and smudge resistant.
- Subtle light diffusers
Specification:
- Brand name: Neutrogena
- Cosmic black
- 1-ounce pencil
Pros
- Beautifies the eye with its bright luminous color
- Easy to draw precision lines and create smokey eyes or any other look you might fancy
- Made with organic materials therefore, it is very nourishing to the skin.
- Works perfectly well for people with sensitive skin and for contact wearers
- Waterproof and smudge resistant. It can last for hours even when you cry or sweat.
- Has an inbuilt sharpener. Wonderful
- Approved by medical experts
Cons
- The pencil breaks off easily
2
L’Oreal Paris Infallible Lacquer Eyeliner
When it comes to luxury goods and beauty products, nobody does it better than the French. Check out this fascinating eyeliner manufactured by L’Oreal. What this amazing product offers is the guarantee can you can step out every day looking beautiful with your cat-eye look or any look you fancy. This 24-hour lasting product is very skin-friendly and glides along the skin in an effortless and stress-free manner. By every standard, this gel formula is one of the best on the market.
Key Features:
- Made from organic products
- Infallible lacquer gel; liquid
- Lasts very long; up to 24 hours
- Smudge-proof
Specification:
- Brand name: L’Oreal Paris
- Black color
- Gel liner
Pros
- Perfect for creating perfectly drawn lines that give you a classic look.
- Lasts very long: up to 24 hours
- Versatile gel formula that keeps you looking good all day.
- Allows for smooth application.
Cons
- Might irritate the eyes if you have a previous injury or something related
3
Neutrogena Precision Liquid Eye Liner
Buying eyeliners that meet your unique needs does not have to be a difficult task any longer. Check out this amazing product manufactured by Neutrogena, rest assured, this eyeliner has been used by different customers all over the world and it is definitely trusted by them.
Everything you need your eyeliner to do for you, Neutrogena precision eyeliner will serve the purpose. This eyeliner is made from a wonderful blend of natural honey and coconut which makes it long-lasting and resistant to external stimuli like sweat and tears. Another important thing to note about this product is the fact that it is allergenic which means it is compatible with all and every skin texture. Applying this product is a very easy process as the precision tip of the pencil allows it to glide carefully and softly in whatever direction or fashion you wish.
Key Features:
- Water-proof and extremely colored
- Made from natural honey and coconut
- Hypoallergenic and suitable for sensitive eyes and faces
- Resistant to an external stimulus
- Pen like design
- Liquid eyeliner
Specification:
- Jet Black color
- Brand name: Neutrogena
- Hypoallergenic beauty product
Pros
- Neutrogena Precision Liquid eyeliner allows for the stress-free application of precise and defined lines
- Compatible with any skin texture and recommended for sensitive due to its hypoallergenic properties.
- Has the ability to stay on the face for a long time without smudging
- Made with a natural blend of honey and coconut.
Cons
- It might be hard to wash off.
- Might itch if you don’t wash it off well.
4
Winged Eyeliner Stamp and Pen 2 in 1
If you have been looking for the perfect organic eyeliner that will take care into account your skin texture and achieve the aim of making you look beautiful at the same time, then this might just be the product you are looking for. This 2 in 1 winged eyeliner is designed to uniquely create a hard line similar to a cat’s own. This look is mostly referred to as the cat-eye look in the beauty space and up until recently, could only be perfectly drawn by a make-up artist. However, with the help of this eyeliner stamp, anybody can achieve this look with just a few strokes of the pencil. This product is made completely from vegan and it is also smudge-proof and water-resistant.
Key Features:
- 2 in 1 make up product
- Made from special vegan ingredients
- Water-resistant
- Jet black coloring
- Compatible with any skin type
Specification:
- 2 in 1 eyeliner stamp
- Brand name: Vicious Technology
- 100 percent organic
Pros
- Capable of drawing a perfectly winged eyeliner that gives women that beautiful cat-eye look.
- Long-lasting due to its smudge-proof and water-resistant attributes.
- A useful tool for beginners and experts alike due to its time-saving advantage.
- It does not affect or irritate the skin of its user.
Cons
- The stamp part of the eyeliner is not very easy to use.
5
Marcelle 2 in 1 Retractable Eyeliner
When it comes to the production of beauty and skincare products, Marcelle can best be described as a veteran in the business. With over 100 years on the beauty products market, you can be sure that this amazing new eyeliner is nothing short of the best. It has been tested by dermatologists and is certified to be completely hypoallergenic and free from fragrance or strong smells. It is also good to note that this product has amazing unique features which when coupled together you the perfect eyeliner.
Key Features:
- Comes with an inbuilt sharpener
- Retractable crayon mechanism
- 2 in 1 liner; a crayon tip and a sponge tip
- Long-lasting and water-resistant
- Dermatologist tested
Specification:
- Retractable crayon
- Charcoal color
- Brand name: Marcelle
- Two-sided eyeliner
Pros
- Sensitive to all skin types due to its hypoallergenic properties and it has been tested by Dermatologists for any side effects
- Waterproof and can last very long
- Serves a 2 in 1 purpose; eyeliner and sponge brush
- Moves softly on the skin
- Creating smokey eyes is easy with this product
Cons
- Can lead to irritation if you don’t wash off properly
6
Better’n Ur Eyes Natural Eyeliner Pencil
Organic products are said to be the skincare products with the least side effects. If you want an eyeliner that fits this description, then this natural eyeliner is just perfect for you. This amazing product manufactured by skin2spirit is made from healing oils, natural waxes, and botanicals. These include shea butter, castor oil, cocoa butter, and a few others. Using this product guarantees you the best organic blend you can find as regards eyeliner products. The non-toxic ingredients make this product hypoallergenic and therefore you can rule out irritation and other skin defects which may arise as continuous use of your eyeliner. This product was manufactured in a cruelty-free setting and no animals were harmed.
Key Features:
- Made from natural oils and botanicals
- Hypoallergenic; compatible with all skin types
- Paraben-free
- Made in the United States of America
- Gluten-free
Specification:
- Dark brown color
- Brand name; Skin2spirit
- Organic eyeliner
Pros
- Tailor-made to suit sensitive eyes
- Easy to apply and long-lasting
- Enriched with natural formulas that you the best skincare
- Contains multiple vitamins
- Produced in a cruelty-free environment
Cons
- This eyeliner is not waterproof.
7
Physicians Formula Eye Booster Lash 2-In-1 Boosting Eyeliner & Serum
Another amazing hypoallergenic eyeliner you can try out is this amazing product manufactured by Physicians Formula. This product doubles as both an eyeliner and an eyelash enhancer. Having a multi-tasking beauty product can save you time, money, and energy. This wonderful product is safe for contact wearers and those with sensitive. It also good to note that the manufacturers of this amazing product have been in the beauty product market for quite some time now (as far back as 1937) therefore that expertise comes to bear during production to make sure you have the best liquid eyeliner with all its added advantages. It lasts long and is resistant to external stimuli. Check out this product!
Key Features:
- 2 in 1 liquid eyeliner
- Dermatologist approved
- Compatible with sensitive skin
- Water-resistant
- Comes with a stiff brush tip
Specification:
- Deep brown color
- Hypoallergenic
- Brand name: Physicians Formula
Pros
- Serves a dual purpose; functions as both a liquid eyeliner and an eyelash booster
- Approved by skin experts for sensitive skin texture
- Safe for contact users
- Draws eyes quite nicely, glides over the skin without causing any distress to the user.
- Made without any of the internationally known harsh ingredients
- Water-resistant and long-lasting
Cons
- Eyeliner content cannot be used for an extended period of time
8
Rimmel Scandal eyes Waterproof Gel Eye Liner Pencil, Black
Over the years, Rimmel has manufactured countless exceptional beauty products one of which is this amazing eyeliner. This waterproof eyeliner has been uniquely designed to fit the needs of women (and men) of all skin types. Another good thing to note is that this Rimmel’s ophthalmologist-tested beauty product is both beautifying and safe for contact wearers and those with sensitive eyes. Go out looking confident because rest assured, this eyeliner won’t get distorted through the course of your day because of its unique ability to withstand tears, stress, sweat, and others. It is also very easy to apply due to its unique formula that allows for friendly contact with the skin. This is definitely a must-have product.
Key Features:
- Pencil like design
- Waterproof
- High-intensity color
- Ultra-smooth and creamy formula
Specification:
- Women’s beauty product
- Black color
- Brand name: Rimmel
Pros
- Tested and verified by ophthalmologists
- Doesn’t run or smudge due to tears or sweat
- Very intense color impact
- Compatible with any skin color
- Suitable for contacts users
- Made with a creamy formula that rolls over well on the skin
Cons
- Might break easily
9
Alma Eyeliner Pencil
Simplicity is often underrated and this is no different from beauty products. Sometimes all you need is a simple product to give you that special look and that is what this unique product by Almay does for you. This eyeliner pencil has been made with the best materials and is highly enriched with vitamin E. it is suitable for people with sensitive and eyelids and it also comes with an in-built sharpener. This product lasts up to 16 hours and is smudge-proof and water-resistant.
Key Features:
- Compatible with sensitive eyes and works for people that use contacts
- Last for up to 16 hours
- Comes with an in-built sharpener
- Nourished with vitamin E
Specification:
- Brand name: Almay
- Black pearl color
- Hypoallergenic
Pros
- Lasts for a longer period of time; up to 16 hours
- Enriched with vitamin E that protects your skin
- Perfect precision tip for drawing winged lines
- Waterproof
Cons
- Might break easily if not properly handled.
- Might be hard to wash off
10
Marcelle Waterproof Eyeliner
Finally, we have this excellent product manufactured by Marcelle. This Hypoallergenic eyeliner embodies many wonderful features and offers added advantages to its users such as being fragrance-free and extra creamy along the eye lines. Drawing lines and creating distinct looks such as the cat-eye look and the smudge look has never been easier. This product is ophthalmologist and dermatologist tested and approved and therefore goes well with almost any skin texture. If you love to stay out all day and you would love your makeup to not leave you hanging, then this product is just right for you.
Key Features:
- Resistant to smudging.
- Can be used to achieve a wide variety of looks
- A very precise and sharp tip
- Lasts for long and waterproof
- Approved by medical experts
- Hypoallergenic and friendly to different types of skins
Specification:
- Brand name: Marcelle.
- Charcoal color.
- Hypoallergenic.
Pros
- It can be easily applied due to the extra creamy texture of the crayon.
- Useful for creating smokey eyes.
- Lasts very long, up to 24 hours.
- Smudge resistant. It does not run easily.
- Approved by medical experts therefore useful for those with sensitive skin.
Cons
- You might need a makeup remover to wash it off.
Buying Guide Questions
Picking out the skin product that works for you perfectly might seem impossible. If you are still unsure about which hypoallergenic mascara to use for your sensitive skin, then answering these questions will go a long way in clearing your doubts and helping you finally decide what is right for you.
Which eyeliner is best for sensitive eyes?
A lot of makeup manufacturers make it a point of duty to create products that don’t have adverse effects on normal skin textures. However, if you have extra sensitive skin, then the best eyeliners for you might be the ones produced with purely organic materials. You have to be careful however if you use expired organic products, it might cause a lot of unforeseen problems. This entire review was put together so you can have a look at the product manufacturers that produce the best hypoallergenic products for sensitive eyes.
Is cream eyeshadow better for sensitive eyes?
If you have sensitive eyes, then a cream eyeshadow is the best choice for you. Powder eyeshadow often contains skin-irritating materials. Furthermore, there is no assurance that particles of your powder shadow won’t fall into your eye when you are applying it. Cream eyeshadows are made from safe materials and they can easily be applied around the eyes provided the pencil glides around the skin effortlessly.
Why do my eyes burn when I wear eyeliner?
Eyeliners that are made with the right hypoallergenic materials and applied correctly by the user should not, ideally speaking cause your eyes to burn. This mostly occurs if the product you are using is substandard, expired, or made with one or more of the 150+ known harsh ingredients. Using bad products can be very dangerous to your skin and eyes and in extreme cases, this could lead to blindness, which is why you need to be very careful when choosing an eyeliner. Applying your eyeliner, the wrong way may also cause your eyes to burn. It could also be that your eyes are extra sensitive. If this is the case, you need to seek advice from medical experts on the best products to get that will serve you perfectly.
What makeup do dermatologists recommend?
Dermatologists don’t outrightly recommend products however, they engage in vetting products before mass production and they encourage customers to buy products with certain labels such as hypoallergenic, non-comedogenic, organic among others. When buying a makeup product, make sure it is clinically tested and approved. Also try your best to make sure that the claims of the seller are true.
Is Almay eyeliner good for sensitive eyes?
Almay produces a variety of beauty products and most of these are hypoallergenic and produced in cruelty-free environments. If you have sensitive eyes, Almay products are perfect for you. However, you still need to make further research on any of their products you might want to get so you can be sure it is right for you. If you search for large eCommerce stores like Amazon, you would see a whole lot of Almay products. Rest assured, you would definitely find one that you can buy and try out.
Conclusion
It is good to look beautiful and attractive when you step outside and have sensitive eyes or skin shouldn’t stop you from using makeup. If you use the right products and follow the instructions, you would be able to put on beautiful makeup just like any other lady out there. This review was put together to help narrow down your decision process.
Above is the list of some of the best hypoallergenic eyeliners you would find on the market. If you have seen something you like (which is more than likely), make further research, read customer reviews, and then get the product. The opportunity to find something that can serve your needs on the long term doesn’t come very often, take advantage of this one and order something good.
Other posts to read on similar topics: